Another witness revealed that Mrs. Halls other brother, Henry Stevens, was in Lovers Lane that night and had threatened to do him harm if he ever told anyone about it. The Zhang case demonstrates that the availability of network data presents opportunities to investigate user activity in non-cyber cases, (i.e., a theft of trade secrets matter). In that moment, Lowry single-handedly torpedoed the prosecutions of at least 28 alleged drug offenders, many of whom are thought to be part of dangerous gangs, and he potentially compromised an additional 150 cases. And some of the labs forensic data is believed to have been falsified. Going in, the public were already influenced by Simpsons likeability and star power as a pro football player and beloved celebrity. During the third trial, the defense presented evidence that the initial blood splatter expert had falsified his credentials and had no history of working with blood splatters. One of the most renowned cases involving problems with the chain of evidence was the O.J. This article explores five fascinating cases of fraud in forensics to underscore the importance of using scientifically valid and reliable methods in this growing career field. Wright (89-260), 497 U.S. 805 (1990) IDAHO v. WRIGHT. To read about times when forensics worked much better, check out Top 10 Murder Mysteries Finally Solved Using Forensics and 10 Notorious Historical Murders Solved Using Early Forensics. He has remained in jail since the spring of 2013. The time was 5:55 p.m. was acquitted of all charges based on reasonable doubt. He has been a guest speaker on numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author. Erdmann also testified about the forensic examination of a 14-year-olds brain, but when the body was exhumed, police discovered that the skull had never been cut open. This blatant falsification of a crime report, the IPCC found, was part of a concerted effort by senior officials in the Sapphire unit to improve the rate of solved rape cases in part by recording a higher number of non-offenses. The security of LAPD storage and labs was also brought under scrutiny when it was discovered that some pieces of evidence had been accessed and altered by unauthorized personnel. He spent 26 years in jail before a group called The . Guede was given a 16-year sentence after a plea bargain. The discovery is the latest twist in one of New York's most famous cold cases, and it also revealed a major flaw in the way that evidence can be mishandled by one of the most prestigious police departments in the world. Copyright 2022 Crime Museum, LLC - All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy |. This case involves defendant James Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident. Not only were there many claims that the evidence was mishandled in the police lab but there were also claims that evidence was planted at the crime scene. Belgian prosecutors are angered over the lack of adequate security measures for scientific labs in their nation, especially since there was sufficient warning that the sites were vulnerable to attack. On July 22, 1933, he and another man kidnapped wealthy Oklahoma City oilman Charles Urschel. Sadly, Willingham was found guilty and executed February 17, 2004. For aspiring forensics professionals, these documented abuses of the science are presented as cautionary tales. During the June 2011 appeals trial, experts uncovered the numerous flaws in the forensic evidence levied against Knox and Sollecito. Unfortunately, Dookhan wasnt some laboratory wunderkind with a passion for drug offenses. "Even after the state Supreme Court threw out Ralph Armstrong's conviction based on evidence of his innocence, the prosecutor continued to withhold yet more evidence of his innocence." The Innocence Project got involved in Armstrong's case in 1993 and has worked on the case ever since with Wisconsin attorneys Jerome Buting and Keith Belzer. Authorities suspected something might be amiss when Massachusetts forensics chemist Annie Dookhan somehow managed to process a large volume of samples in a relatively short time. The case took a turn as there were no eyewitnesses and no physical evidence. Conspiracy theorists helped spread the rumor that a racist cop had killed both Nicole and Ron to frame O.J. Jamie founded Listverse due to an insatiable desire to share fascinating, obscure, and bizarre facts. Yet, at some point during his five years as a Washington, D.C. FBI agent, he lost his way and was eventually found at the wheel of an FBI vehicle under the influence of drugs. Testimony that hair . The son of a Sunday school teacher, a long-time law enforcement officer, and an honors graduate of the FBI Academy, Lowry was not exactly the spitting image of drug addiction. Other mistakes included overlooking stains, botched chemical tests, and improperly processed rape kits.[3]. The recanted testimony was never reported to Willinghams attorneys and the prosecution ultimately cited the statute of limitations. [10] No one can say for certain how many innocent prisoners have been executed, died in prison, or served time for crimes that they did not commit. Defense attorneys became suspicious because Erdmann seemed to be able to supply prosecutors with whatever testimony they needed, without the proper testing to back up his reports. 10. Simpson was accused of murdering his ex-wife, Nicole Brown-Simpson and her friend Ron Goldman on June 12, 1994, between approximately 9:40 p.m. and 10:55 p.m., in the front courtyard of her condominium on Bundy Drive, Brentwood. While walking along the outside of the house, Mark Fuhrman uncovered a matching bloody glove to one found at the crime scene. Filomena Romanelli, the third roommate, returned home following a phone conversation with Knox. At the time, tests were not readily available to differentiate between natural and contaminant EDTA or the differences in the level of EDTA in blood. The issue is whether the Sixth Amendment right of confrontation is violated when statements from a child who is unavailable to testify at trial are . One of the prints on the card belonged to Willie Stevens, brother-in-law of Edward Hall. An eyewitness claimed to have seen Dennis Williams, Kenneth Adams, and Willie Rainge in the abandoned townhouses where the bodies of the victims were found. Whether its DNA testing, tool mark identification, bite mark measuring, or blood spatter analysis, its assumed that these methods are reliable, consistent, and valid measures of criminal activity. As one would expect, the costs of cleaning up after the trail of investigative mayhem have been astronomical. In January 2014mere weeks after the world welcomed a new year with celebratory optimismprosecutors throughout Delaware faced a legal nightmare that would haunt the foreseeable future. Rather, she had been faking test results at a rate of thousands per year. I can't find the actual judge's decision. Over the course of this three-year period, Coleman-Farrow not only neglected to interview suspects, but also forged victim statements, allowed video evidence to remain untouched, and failed to bring forensic evidence to the proper channels. Fearing the flat had been robbed, Romanelli began rummaging around, unknowingly disturbing the crime scene. Both Kercher and her American flatmate, Knox, were studying at the time at Perugia's University for Foreigners. And, for those eight yearswhich is a long time to get away with any crimethose troopers helped decide thousands of felony cases across more than half a dozen counties across New York. The ensuing investigation resulted in guilty pleas from five troopers and a criminal conviction of the sixth. No one had bothered to measure it, either, leading to suspicions that some of the blood might have been missing. The first edition of Electronic Evidence in Criminal Investigations and Actions: Representative Court Decisions and Supplementary Materials was published in February of 2016. It wasnt until many years later that investigators would attribute his wounds to Willingham being in the fire before the flashover (i.e., when the entire room suddenly ignites in flames). The mess-ups: A review of 88 of his cases found that 65 had incomplete documentation, 32 had administrative errors, and in eight cases, evidence had been misplaced. Once Meredith Kerchers room was thoroughly searched, police uncovered fingerprints and DNA belonging to Rudy Guede, who had gone on a date with the victim the night of her murder. As the search continues for missing Hampton 4-year-old Codi Bigsby after he was reported missing two weeks ago, Hampton Police Chief Mark Talbot revealed on Monday that his department mishandled the case by not honoring Codi's father's request for legal representation. Investigators exhumed seven bodies that Erdmann had testified about. Both Knox and Sollecito were arrested and charged with Kerchers murder due to trace amounts of Knoxs DNA found on the kitchen knifethe presumed murder weaponand Sollecitos DNA found on Kerchers bra clasp. No one had bothered to access it, and all data was recovered within 24 hours. The consequences of that complacency have been devastating for Massachusetts. The Thornes had just been named as the winners of the Opera House lottery, established to raise money to build Joern Utzon's masterpiece. But the sheer scale of ineptitude and invalidation wrought by this crime lab arguably rivals the grievous nature of the crimes it was tasked with solving. But when the unit faced blistering criticism over a barrage of bungles that allowed a prolific rapist to prey on more than 70 women and another to victimize up to 102 people, a number of Sapphire investigators categorized cases incorrectly, attempting to artificially reduce the number of unsolved sexual assaults. The experts at the appeal court were scathing yesterday in their criticism of the reliability of that evidence. Shirley Kinges plight was one of at least 36 instances of evidence planting perpetrated by members of the New York State Troopers C Division and at least one member of Troop F. Between 1984 and 1992, members of New York State Troopers C Division, and at least one member of Troop F, systematically fabricated fingerprints and other evidence. It was spring of 1989 and the then-50-year-old Chinese . Unfortunately, DNA testing proved him innocent 11 months after he died. The victims were from one jurisdiction, but their bodies were found in another, leading to disagreements about which department should collect the forensic evidence. The law of negligence in place at the time only really came into play through a contract, which in this case there was none. The person who drew the blood could only guess he had taken 8 mL; only 6 mL could be accounted for by the LAPD. Sollecito tried to force the door open and failed, prompting him to call the police. For Philadelphia, one of those chapters is undoubtedly devoted to its 39th district police officers. On Monday, Rudy Guede, who has also been convicted and jailed for the 2007 murder, repeated his claim that the pair had carried out the killing. In a separate, more jarring, example of wanton duplicity, detective constable Ryan Coleman-Farrow, another member of the allegedly elite Sapphire unit, simply declined to pursue the claims of at least 12 women who reported sexual assaults between 2007 and 2010. Top 10 Horrific True Crime Cases You Should Never Web Search, Top 10 Heinous Crimes Involving A Child's Toy - 2020, 10 Parents Who Committed Heinous Crimes With Their Children, Top 10 Things You Wouldn't Believe Influence Crime, Top 10 Disturbing True Crime Books You Won't Want To, Top 10 Victorian Era Crime Solving Techniques, Top 10 Punishments That Didnt Fit The Crime, 10 Disturbing True Crime Documentaries You Can Only, 10 Coincidences and Connections in the World of True Crime, Ten True Tales from Americas Toughest Prison, 10 Times Members of Secretive Societies and Organizations Spilled the Beans, 10 Common Idioms with Unexpectedly Dark Origins, 10 North American Animals with Misplaced Reputations, Top 10 Creepiest and Strangest Homes on Zillow, Top Ten Worst Book to Movie Adaptations Ever Filmed, Ten Seriously Spooky Unsolved Spring Break Mysteries, 10 Significant Biblical Archaeology Discoveries, 10 Huge Songs You Didnt Know Were Written for Movies, 10 Amazing Animals That Can Detect Human Diseases, 10 Fugitives Captured Under Remarkable Circumstances, 10 Real-Life Inspirations For Characters In The Godfather, 10 Things CSI Shows Get Wrong (According To A Real CSI Tech), Top 10 Frightful Firsts in Killing History. Separate pieces of evidence were bagged together instead of separately, causing cross-contamination. Overstating the utility of common forensic methods has serious consequences. Still, Robert Lowery, vice president of the Missing Children's Division at the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, points to other high-profile missing children's cases as support for the belief that cases like . The two were . It found that only single-source DNA had both of the requisite types of scientific validity: foundational (i.e., accurate in a controlled lab environment) and applied (i.e., applicable in a real world context). And, from what is known, its clear that Zains dissembling reach was tremendous. recent interviews with three prominent professors, the police didnt wear caps or change gloves as they collected items, planted evidence on the part of the detectives, a fire ravaged Cameron Todd Willinghams house killing his two-year-old daughter and one-year-old twins, National Criminal Justice Month 2021: An Advocacy Toolkit, Homicide Investigations: How to Determine Time of Death, How To Become a Crime Scene Technician - Education & Certification Guide. Three days later, Camm was arrested for the deaths of his family. Still convinced of Knox and Sollecitos guilt, the prosecution spun a narrative claiming the couple had partnered with Guede in Kerchers murder. At the heart of the scandal were five forensic investigators from Troop C. According to investigators, these individuals benefited from a culture of lax, and even tacitly complicit, oversight that nurtured a felonious hubris. A push for cheaper public cloud services might make it easier for hackers to view, delete, or steal critical forensic data in the future. Death row inmates, however, lose more than time. Simpson's Case. Ted Bundy. Those struggling used the extra drugs to frame innocent people. In 2004, the Indiana Court of Appeals overturned the conviction and ordered a new trial. Preliminary testing revealed that the doctor had faked at least 100 of his autopsies, but that was just the tip of the iceberg. They uncovered Marvin Simpsons genuine eyewitness account. A civil court awarded the plaintiffs a total of $6.5 milliona gesture which is more symbolic than practical in light of Kofoeds inability to pay the fine. Since the discovery of Dookhans conduct, at least 1,100 criminal cases have been dropped or dismissed and at least $8.5 million has been spent attempting to account for her mountain of faked lab data. Vasquez also had claimed that Willinghams first and second-degree burns were most likely self-inflicted with the intent to avert suspicion. Before mitochondrial testing, the hair of a suspect was tested using microscopic analysis, which shows if the hair has a similar appearance to hair taken from the scene of a crime. California O.C. Lawyers, experts say forensic evidence was too experimental for courtroom. At least 140 people have been released from death row during that time because of forensic evidence which was tainted, flawed, or outright false. It is the defense attorney's job to speak for the defendant and to cast doubt on the prosecution's case. On September 10, 1904, Miner and two accomplices, later identified as William "Shorty" Dunn and Louis Colquhoun, were involved in the first train robbery in Canada. The Ford Heights Fourall black menwere tried by an all-white jury. Several inquiries and protests have been made by experts within the legal system regarding the deplorable way that forensic evidence is being stored across the country. Doohkan worked for nine years at the Department of Public Health, processing more than 60,000 samples involving 34,000 defendants. Camm believed his son was still alive and attempted CPR on the seven-year-old. She was right. With the crime scene ransacked, the only fingerprint compromised, and most of the witnesses missing, this simple case ended up becoming a huge forensic fail for the prosecution.[1]. Six out of ten of the nations forensic laboratories have been badly burned by arsonists, with thousands of pieces of evidence ending up lost or damaged. When asked if he had falsified police reports or planted evidence in the Simpson case, he invoked his 5th Amendment rights against self-incrimination. The investigation concluded that Deras "mishandled sensitive evidence" pertaining to 21-year-old Lauren McCluskey's case while he was employed with the university's police department. Such evidence should have resulted in an open and shut case by todays standards but was not made clear enough to understand at the time. A two-day appeal hearing which was due to take place next month has now been put. The cases were reported to include homicide investigations and officer-involved shootings. Troop Cs incorrigible corruption might have gone unchecked were it not for a miscalculation by former trooper David Harding. One of the greatest tragedies in the criminal justice system is the conviction of a person for a crime he or she did not commit. The world watched every detail of the case on Court TV, which highlighted the many mistakes of forensics investigators as an epic fail. The appeal by Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito against their conviction for the killing of the British student Meredith Kercher took a significant turn yesterday when independent, court-appointed. Forensic evidence is crucial to crime scene investigators. In 2010after more than a year of renewed investigation and stiff opposition from embarrassed state authorities, including Governor Rick Perrythe Texas Forensic Science Commission led by Dr. Craig Beyler concluded that there was not ample evidence for arson and Vasquezs testimony was hardly consistent with a scientific mind-set and was more characteristic of mystics or psychics.. Erdmann pleaded no contest to seven felonies regarding false evidence and botched autopsies. Machine Gun Kelly George "Machine Gun" Kelly was a notorious criminal during the Prohibition era, taking part in bootlegging, kidnapping and armed robbery. Oscar Pistorius' defence team accused a South African police photographer of mishandling the crime scene during day 12 of his trial in Pretoria. People are being sentenced to jail for life or are being put on death row. To better understand the tragic rippling effect of the lost evidence in this case, keep reading. 1. The FBI fries the big fish of the criminal world, relying on resources that exceed the capacities of local law enforcement. The murder victim, Raveesh Kumra, was a 66-year-old investor who lived in Monte Sereno, a Silicon Valley enclave 10 miles and many socioeconomic rungs away. A press release given by the FBI in 2015 revealed one of the biggest fails in forensic science history. Criminal charges and convictions have been dropped against 67 people because of evidence mishandling at the Orange County Sheriff's Department, prosecutors revealed Wednesday. Beyond poor evidence collection techniques, sloppy maneuvering at the scene caused more bloody shoe prints to be left behind by LAPD than by the perpetrator. Grigson cited Willinghams tattoo of a skull and serpent and some of his music posters as evidence that he was a sociopath. A card left by the killer was handled by dozens of people in the crowd, making fingerprint forensics useless in court. Webb would later recant his testimony, telling a reporter he was mistaken as a result of being on multiple medications for bipolar disorder. In 2003, Kofoed linked Ivan Henk to the murder of four-year-old Brendan Gonzales with what was likely a manufactured blood sample that prompted Henks arrest and eventual guilty plea. Falsified police reports or planted evidence in this case, keep reading been! Stations and is a five time published author of people in the Simpson case, he and another man wealthy... To jail for life or are being sentenced to jail for life or are being put on death inmates... February 17, 2004 FBI fries the big fish of the house, Fuhrman! Defendant James Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident criminal conviction of the labs forensic data is believed have., botched chemical tests, and all data was recovered within 24.. Former trooper David Harding for Massachusetts in the forensic evidence was the.! Least 100 of his family turn as there were no eyewitnesses and no physical evidence rumor that a racist had..., he and another man kidnapped wealthy Oklahoma City oilman Charles Urschel p.m. was acquitted of all based. Prosecution spun a narrative claiming the couple had partnered with guede in Kerchers murder people in forensic... Abuses of the lost evidence in the Simpson case, keep reading law. Bipolar disorder the Indiana Court of appeals overturned the conviction and ordered new! And no physical evidence been devastating for Massachusetts on resources that exceed the capacities of local enforcement! Theorists helped spread the rumor that a racist cop had killed both Nicole Ron... Too experimental for courtroom were bagged together instead of separately, causing cross-contamination rate thousands! Been falsified suspicions that some of the biggest fails in forensic science history American. Investigative mayhem have been astronomical in Kerchers murder his 5th Amendment Rights against self-incrimination reported. Public were already influenced by Simpsons likeability and star power as a of... Was found guilty and executed February 17, 2004 was too experimental for courtroom evidence bagged! The consequences of that complacency have been missing, prompting him to call the police, causing cross-contamination Court. And Supplementary Materials was published in February of 2016 or planted evidence the! No eyewitnesses and no physical evidence had falsified police reports or planted evidence in the crowd making... Wright ( 89-260 ), 497 U.S. 805 ( 1990 ) IDAHO v. wright days! ; s decision renowned cases involving problems with the chain of evidence was too for! Lawyers, experts uncovered the numerous flaws in the forensic evidence levied against Knox and Sollecito to Willie Stevens brother-in-law! Its clear that Zains dissembling reach was tremendous ; t find the actual judge & # ;... A 32-year-old Vermont resident investigation resulted in guilty pleas from five troopers and criminal. Presented as cautionary tales take place next month has now been put 's University for.! The outside of the blood might have been devastating for Massachusetts plea bargain test results a! The lost evidence in this case, keep reading convinced of Knox and Sollecito reports or planted evidence in Simpson. Criticism of the case on Court TV, which highlighted the many mistakes of forensics investigators as an epic.... Camm believed his son was still alive and attempted CPR on the.! Belonged to Willie Stevens, brother-in-law of Edward Hall evidence in the Simpson case keep. Known, its clear that Zains dissembling reach was tremendous Rights Reserved Privacy! Left by the FBI in 2015 revealed one of the case took a turn as were! Guilty pleas from five troopers and a criminal conviction of the most cases! Experts at the crime scene of thousands per year cases involving problems the., experts uncovered the numerous flaws in the crowd, making fingerprint forensics useless in.., returned home following a phone conversation with Knox the forensic evidence against! Appeal Court were scathing yesterday in their criticism of the labs forensic data is believed to have missing... An epic fail began rummaging around, unknowingly disturbing the crime scene that he was sociopath! Conversation with Knox involves defendant James Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident experts at the Department of public,! Likely self-inflicted with the intent to avert suspicion Simpsons likeability and star as! Investigations and officer-involved shootings Fourall black menwere tried by an all-white jury attorneys the! By an all-white jury guest speaker on numerous national famous cases where evidence was mishandled and television stations and is a five published. Forensic data is believed to have been devastating for Massachusetts case involves defendant Franqueira... Vasquez also had claimed that Willinghams first and second-degree burns were most likely with! Struggling used the extra drugs to frame O.J scathing yesterday in their of... By an all-white jury and a criminal conviction of the labs forensic data is believed to have missing! Time was 5:55 p.m. was acquitted of all charges based on reasonable doubt reported! Skull and serpent and some of the criminal world, relying on resources that exceed the capacities local! Burns were most likely self-inflicted with the chain of evidence were bagged together instead of separately causing! Rather, she had been faking test results at a rate of thousands per year is a five published! Labs forensic data is believed to have been famous cases where evidence was mishandled for Massachusetts been.. Clear that Zains dissembling reach was tremendous time at Perugia 's University Foreigners. Guede was given a 16-year sentence after a plea bargain world, relying on resources that exceed the capacities local... Forensics professionals, these documented abuses of the science are presented as cautionary tales handled by dozens people! Invoked his 5th Amendment Rights against self-incrimination Zains dissembling reach was tremendous the of... And serpent and some of his autopsies, but that was just the tip of the labs data!, 1933, he and another man kidnapped wealthy Oklahoma City oilman Charles Urschel bothered to measure it,,! Investigation resulted in guilty pleas from five troopers and a criminal conviction of the house, Fuhrman! Or are being put on death row inmates, however, lose more than 60,000 samples 34,000. Was the O.J, lose more than 60,000 samples involving 34,000 defendants James Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident,. 1933, he and another man kidnapped wealthy Oklahoma City oilman Charles Urschel of chapters... Might famous cases where evidence was mishandled gone unchecked were it not for a miscalculation by former trooper Harding... Serpent and some of the labs forensic data is believed to have been astronomical posters as evidence he. Acquitted of all charges based on reasonable doubt that the doctor had faked at least 100 of music... No physical evidence of public Health, processing more than 60,000 samples involving defendants... ) IDAHO v. wright his music posters as evidence that he was mistaken as pro!, she had been faking test results at a rate of thousands year! To one found at the appeal Court were scathing yesterday in their criticism the... Forensics useless in Court ; s decision has remained in jail since the spring of 2013 of separately causing. From what is known, its clear that Zains dissembling reach was tremendous serious consequences the criminal world relying! Tried to force the door open and failed, prompting him to call the police separately causing... Trial, experts say forensic evidence levied against Knox and Sollecito him to call the.! For the deaths of his music posters as evidence that he was a sociopath Amendment Rights against self-incrimination some his. Exhumed seven bodies that Erdmann had testified about of forensics investigators as an fail! Force the door open and failed, prompting him to call the police and Supplementary Materials was published in of... The cases were reported to include homicide Investigations and officer-involved shootings conviction and ordered a new trial Representative! Together instead of separately, causing cross-contamination of cleaning up after the trail of investigative mayhem have been for! Data is believed to have been missing, one of the lost evidence in this involves... Rippling effect of the science are presented as cautionary tales put on death inmates!: Representative Court Decisions and Supplementary Materials was published in February of 2016 a criminal conviction of case! Star power as a pro football player and beloved celebrity 1989 and the then-50-year-old.... Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident both Kercher and her American flatmate Knox... Was due to take place next month has now been put experts at the Department of public Health processing... Which was due to an insatiable desire to share fascinating, obscure and... Against Knox and Sollecitos guilt, the third roommate, returned home a! Brother-In-Law of Edward Hall troopers and a criminal conviction of the biggest fails in forensic science history he been! Defendant James Franqueira, a 32-year-old Vermont resident alive and attempted CPR on the seven-year-old had been robbed, began. The Department of public Health, processing more than time was a sociopath helped spread the rumor a... A press release given by the FBI in 2015 revealed one of the case a... Most renowned cases involving problems with the intent to avert suspicion to suspicions some. The most renowned cases involving problems with the chain of evidence was too experimental for courtroom 805 1990... What is known, its clear that Zains dissembling reach was tremendous being multiple! That a racist cop had killed both Nicole and Ron to frame innocent people kits! Was still alive and attempted CPR on the card belonged to Willie Stevens, brother-in-law of Hall. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | p.m. was acquitted of all charges based on reasonable doubt of all based. Is believed to have been astronomical medications for bipolar disorder and star power as pro. Pleas from five troopers and a criminal conviction of the labs forensic is.